Apple receives FTC support for strong encryption Apfelpatient

For years, Apple has positioned itself as a company that consistently focuses on data protection and strong encryption. In doing so, it has repeatedly found itself on a collision course with governments demanding the installation of technical backdoors into its systems. End-to-end encryption, in particular, has been at the center of these disputes. Recent developments now show that Apple is not only under pressure in Europe and the UK, but has also experienced a surprising turn of events in the US: The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is supporting the company and openly opposes weakening encryption.

Apple's stance is uncompromising. The company even withdrew a key privacy feature from the UK market rather than accept a backdoor globally. The EU also introduced new requirements with the Digital Services Regulation (DSA) that could be problematic for Apple and other tech giants. The recent about-turn in the US came as a surprise. Where previously the FBI and the government exerted massive pressure, the White House is now positioning itself on the side of strong encryption. The FTC is going even further, urging Apple and other companies not to give in to regulatory demands that would weaken encryption.

The US’s contradictory stance on encryption

US policy surrounding encryption has long been inconsistent. Apple was already embroiled in a dispute with the FBI, which demanded access to suspects' encrypted iPhones. Trump declared at the time that Apple must be required to install backdoors. He took the same line in 2020. In 2019, the FBI had emphasized that end-to-end encryption was infecting law enforcement. But in 2022, the tone changed. Suddenly, the US government spoke out against backdoors in iCloud encryption. Trump himself even threatened to terminate a trade agreement with Great Britain if London didn't back down—which ultimately happened.

Apple under pressure from the EU and Great Britain

Apple wasn't just in the spotlight in the US. The EU also put the company under pressure with the Digital Services Act. This regulation requires platforms to actively combat the dissemination of child sexual abuse material (CSAM). Some interpretations of the law imply that this would only be possible through backdoors in encrypted systems. Apple responded similarly to the UK, where it removed a data protection feature entirely from the market to avoid having to compromise on encryption globally.

The role of the FTC

The FTC addressed the debate and clarified that companies in the US risk legal consequences if they weaken encryption. In a letter to Apple and other technology companies, it emphasized that consumers would be deceived if services promised security or encryption without actually offering end-to-end encryption. The agency also argued that international regulations such as the DSA should not be implemented in a way that endangers US citizens. In particular, the restriction of freedom of expression and the loss of security contradict US law. FTC Chairman Andrew Ferguson explicitly stated that he would not hesitate to enforce the law if companies broke their promises to provide encryption.

What this means for Apple

The situation seems almost paradoxical. Just a few years ago, the US government threatened Apple if it insisted on encryption. Today, the FTC threatens companies if they weaken their systems. This is a positive development for data protection. Apple benefits from this about-face. The US government's clear stance strengthens the company internationally, especially in disputes with Europe and Great Britain. For users, this means that strong end-to-end encryption will continue to exist. Another change of course in the US would be politically difficult to justify and would undermine the government's credibility.

Apple finds a powerful partner in the FTC

Ultimately, it turns out that Apple's uncompromising stance is a long-term winner. The FTC's support makes it clear that strong encryption is not just a technical issue, but also a political issue of international significance. For now, the US's new line represents a clear confirmation: end-to-end encryption remains a central component of digital security – and Apple has gained a powerful ally on this issue. (Image: Shutterstock / Vector_iconic)